This website uses cookies.
Office of the Election Supervisor for the International Brotherhood of Teamsters

Frankian, 2026 ESD 130

OFFICE OF THE ELECTION SUPERVISOR

for the

INTERNATIONAL BROTHERHOOD OF TEAMSTERS

 

 

IN RE: FRANKIAN              )                       Protest Decision 2026 ESD 130

                                                )

Protestor.                                 )                       Issued: November 19, 2026

                                                )

                                                )                       OES Case Nos. P-162-090226

                                                                                                 

INTRODUCTION

Jared Frankian filed this post-election protest on or about September 2, 2026, against Justin Scott, President and Principal Officer of Local Union 431, of which Frankian is a member, and Gilbert Prieto, Secretary-Treasurer of Local Union 431. The protest alleges that Scott in particular retaliated against Frankian for his election-related activities in the 2026 Delegate election at the local by advancing for a hearing internal union charges filed against Frankian by another Local 431 member, Jeff Galleguillos. Frankian alleges the charges were without merit and should have been dismissed without a hearing.

Frankian was elected delegate from Local 431 on the Solidarity Slate, which defeated the United For Change (UFC) Slate headed by Scott. The two slates’ rivalries extend back to the local union officers election in 2025 in which the UFC Slate defeated the incumbent Solidarity Slate. The internal union charges which Frankian asserts were baseless, and upon which this protest turns, involved the sharing of personal medical information of a Local 431 member by Frankian with several other members of the union. Previously, the Election Supervisor found that as President and Principal Officer Scott retaliated against Frankian by removing him from his position as union steward for participating in union election activities. See Frankian, 2026 ESD 46.

For the reasons detailed below, we DENY the protest.

OES investigator Deborah Schaff investigated the protest.

 

RELEVANT BACKGROUND

 

Local 431 and the Frankian Protests

 

We recount the circumstances of the previous Frankian protests to the extent they are relevant to the protest at issue here. Local 431 is a general local union headquartered in Fresno, California with members employed by companies involved in shipping, warehouses, disposal and beverage distribution, including UPS and Sun-Maid. Frankian is an employee of UPS and served as a shop steward since 2019. Local 431 was previously led by members of the Solidarity Slate, including President Steve Sharp. In September 2025 Frankian was appointed by the Local 431 Executive Board as a Business Representative, a paid position. In December 2025, Frankian supported Sharp and the Solidarity Slate in their unsuccessful bid for local officer re-election against the United for Change Slate.

 

After ouster of the Solidarity Slate, Scott assumed the position of President and Principal Officer of Local 431. By letter dated January 1, 2026, Scott notified Frankian that his employment as Business Representative was terminated. Scott wrote that the decision was the result of the realignment of Local 431’s organizational structure and was “in no way a reflection of your dedication to this office.” Upon his termination as Business Representative, Frankian returned to his role as shop steward.

 

Local 431 was designated 3 delegates and 1 alternate delegate to the Convention. During the evening of January 8, 2026, the local union held its delegate nomination meeting during which two complete slates were nominated. Scott, Prieto, Jeno Espinoza, Local 431 Vice President, and Andrew Finch (alternate) comprised the United for Change slate. In opposition, Frankian, Sharp, Christopher Garlick, and Robert Mejia (alternate) were nominated as the Solidarity Slate. Four days later, on January 12, 2026, Frankian received a letter dated January 8, signed by Scott (the “January 8 Letter”) terminating his role as shop steward. In that letter, Scott wrote:

 

Leadership has determined to move in a different direction with steward representation at this facility…. This decision reflects the Local’s assessment of its current representational needs and expectations for the role of Shop Steward and is made in the interest of ensuring effective and consistent representation for the membership.

 

Scott provided no other reason for the termination of Frankian’s role as shop steward in the letter. United States Postal Service (USPS) tracking records revealed that the January 8 Letter was received by USPS for mailing on January 10, 2026, two days after the nomination meeting.

 

Frankian filed a protest asserting retaliation for his discharge as steward based on his decision to seek election as a Convention delegate. During the subsequent investigation, Scott informed the investigator that he removed Frankian as shop steward because Frankian was trying to undermine his leadership. According to Scott, that belief was based on a series of text messages that were provided to him by a shop steward at Sun-Maid. The investigation revealed, however, that (a) the subject text messages were sent approximately two weeks after the date of the January 8 Letter, and (b) the Sun Maid shop steward did not provide the text messages to Scott until February 5, 2026. Thus, based on the January 10 mailing indicated on the USPS records and the lack of credible alternative explanation for Frankian’s removal as shop steward, the Election Supervisor found that Scott retaliated against Frankian in violation of the Rules and ordered his reinstatement.

 

On or about January 12, 2026, the Executive Board, led by Scott and Prieto, also caused to be posted on local union bulletin boards a notice written by Prieto on Local 431 letterhead and bearing the names of the four Unity for Change candidates for delegate election. That notice purported to update members on an investigation regarding accrued sick and vacation time payouts made to the outgoing administration, some of whom were members of the Solidarity Slate. In granting Frankian’s protest, the Election Supervisor found the notice to contain several statements that were “either inaccurate or misleading,” and that appeared “intended to discredit the candidates for delegate election on the Solidarity Slate.” Frankian, 2026 ESD 49.

 

P-162-090226

            With that background in mind, we turn to the present protest. Frankian complains that Scott and Prieto, in collusion with Galleguillos, the charging party, retaliated against Frankian for running successfully and serving as a delegate at the IBT Convention, held June 15-18, 2026, in Las Vegas. Frankian provided evidence that Galleguillos was a supporter of the UFC Slate.[1] Our investigator obtained a copy of the charge filed by Galleguillos against Frankian. The charge alleges that Frankian told Galleguillos and other Local 431 members that “SD”[2] had agreed to donate a kidney to Frankian’s brother. Sharing this information was alleged by Galleguillos to violate the IBT Constitution.[3] On behalf of the Executive Board (“eBoard”), Scott subsequently sent a letter by certified mail to Frankian informing him of the charges and that an eBoard trial was set for September 10, 2026 (since extended and still pending by Frankian’s request).

            This protest is relatively straightforward. The only substantive issue raised is whether the protestor has met his burden to show that his election-related activity, running successfully as a candidate for delegate, was a motivating factor in Scott’s decision to send the charges to the eBoard for trial. Or, alternatively, did Scott have a reasonable, independent basis to pursue the charges against Frankian.

 

            Scott told our investigator that he reviewed the charges he received from Galleguillos, as the Constitution requires. He noted that Galleguillos included specific details regarding Frankian’s actions and offered to proffer witnesses to support the charges. Scott noted that ‘sharing personal information about a fellow member with other members and/or management’ is prohibited and if proved also violates the IBT Constitution and Membership Oath by knowingly harming another member and/or bringing shame upon the Union. Therefore, according to Scott, he had ample information to satisfy the Constitutional requirement to bring the charges to trial and would have been remiss in not doing so. Peter McEntee, Scott’s counsel, has represented Local 431 for many years, and he noted that it has long been its practice to proceed to internal trial if charges are filed by anyone for any reason.

     

            The long-time attorney for the Local stated that every charge made against a member is forwarded to the eBoard for a hearing.

 

            Frankian claims the charges as written did not meet the Constitutional requirements for setting an internal Union trial:

 

“The missing information in the charging document matters because [A]rticle [XIX 1b] (IBT [C]onstitution) required the executive board review the charges before they served me. The constitution says the executive board ‘shall review charges and dismiss them’ if conduct being alleged is not something I can be disciplined for.

Same [A]rticle [S]ection 1c requires the written charges to explain what I supposedly did wrong. The issue is how the executive board reviewed these charges and decided they were valid enough to move forward when the charges don’t even say what part of the constitution or bylaws I supposedly violated[.] If the charges do not identify the actual offense or timeline what did the executive board rely on when it decided not to dismiss the charges???”

 

In essence, while admitting that he shared personal medical information about a Union member with other members, Frankian argues that the charge by Galleguillos failed to cite the specific provision of the IBT Constitution or Local 431’s bylaws that he supposedly violated.

 

ANALYSIS

 

This protest is controlled by Article XIII, Section 3 of the Rules, which provides:

 

Post-election protests shall only be considered and remedied if the alleged violation may have affected the outcome of the election, except that any timely protest alleging improper threats, coercion, intimidation, acts of violence or retaliation for exercising any right protected by these Rules shall be considered and remedied without regard to whether the alleged violation affected the outcome of an election.

 

Article XIII, Section 3(b).

 

Article VI, Section 12(a) of the Rules provides that “[a]ll Union members retain the right to participate in Campaign activities, including the right to run for office, to support or oppose any candidate, to aid or campaign for any candidate, and to make personal campaign contributions.” Retaliation by the International Union, any subordinate body, any member of the IBT, any employer or other person or entity against a Union member, officer or employee for exercising any right guaranteed by [the Rules] is prohibited. Article VI, Section 12(g); Hoffa, P812 (August 16, 1996).

 

To prevail on a claim of retaliation, “the evidence must demonstrate that (1) the alleged victim engaged in activity protected by the Rules, (2) the charged party took adverse action against the alleged victim, and (3) the protected activity was a motivating factor in the adverse action.” Cooper, 2005 ESD 8 (September 2, 2005). The Election Supervisor will not find retaliation if he concludes that the union officer or entity would have taken the same action even in the absence of the protestor’s protected conduct. Gilmartin, P32 (January 5, 1996), aff’d, 95 EAM 75. See also Miner, 2005 ESD 1 (May 27, 2005); Link, 2011 ESD 207 (April 12, 2011); Leal, P51 (October 3, 1995), aff’d, 95 EAM 30; Wsol, P95 (September 20, 1995), aff’d, 95 EAM 17.

In this case, Frankian has alleged that Scott, Prieto, and Galleguillos conspired to retaliate against him for his protected election activity. The record does not support that allegation. Although Frankian engaged in activity protected by the Rules by running for and serving as a delegate—months ago, from January to June—he has produced no evidence demonstrating that his protected activity was a motivating factor in the filing, review, or processing of the internal union charges against him. Whether the underlying charge should be dismissed outright, or whether there is any merit to the charge, are matters for the Local 431eBoard to determine, not for the Election Supervisor to decide. The relevant question is whether protected election activity motivated the challenged conduct, and on that issue, Frankian has offered only speculation rather than evidence. Under Article XIII, Section 1 of the Rules, the protestor bears the burden of proving a Rules violation, and that burden has not been met here.[4]

FINDING

 

The protestor has not met his burden to establish that he was retaliated against for

exercising his rights under the Rules. If he is correct that the charge filed against him by his union brother is without merit and should have been dismissed outright he has a remedy with the eBoard.

 

            For the foregoing reasons, the protest is DENIED. 

 

 

APPELLATE RIGHTS

Any interested party not satisfied with this determination may request a hearing before the Election Appeals Master within three (3) working days of receipt of this decision. Any party requesting a hearing must comply with the requirements of Article XIII, Section 3(f). All parties are reminded that, absent extraordinary circumstances, no party may rely in any such appeal upon evidence that was not presented to the Office of the Election Supervisor. Requests for a hearing shall be made in writing, shall specify the basis for the appeal, and shall be served upon:

Election Appeals Master

Barbara Jones

Election Appeals Master

IBTappealsmaster@bracewell.com

 

Copies of the request for hearing must be served upon the parties, as well as upon the Election Supervisor for the International Brotherhood of Teamsters. Service may be accomplished by email, using the “reply all” function on the email by which the party received this decision. A copy of the protest must accompany the request for hearing.

Timothy S. Hillman

Election Supervisor

 

cc: Barbara Jones, IBTappealsmaster@bracewell.com

 

DISTRIBUTION LIST (BY EMAIL UNLESS NOTED OTHERWISE):

Jared Frankian

jjfrankian@yahoo.com

 

 

Justin Scott

justin@teamster431.org

 

Gilbert Prieto

gilbert@teamster431.org

 

Richard Hooker

hookabrasi@gmail.com

 

John Palmer

Jpalmer8734@gmail.com

 

Edward M. Gleason, Jr.,

ed@hsglawgroup.com

 

James L. Donovan Jr.

Jdonovan.ne@gmail.com

 

David Suetholz

dsuetholz@teamster.org

 

Will Bloom

wbloom@dsgchicago.com

 

Ken Paff

ken@tdu.org

 

Thomas Kokalas

thomas.kokalas@bracewell.com

 

Hon. Timothy S. Hillman

thillman@ibtvote.org

 

Deborah Schaaf

dschaaf@ibtvote.org

 

Paul Dever

pdever@ibtvote.org

 

Joe Childers

joe@jchilderslaw.com

 

Kelly Hogan

kelly.hogan@nelsonmullins.com



[1] Two Facebook posts were provided which depict Galleguillos supporting the UFC Slate.

[2] The identity of “SD” is being withheld to protect SD’s privacy.

[3] No specific provision of the IBT Constitution prohibiting the sharing of personal medical information was provided; however, it was alleged by Respondents that it is widely known that such conduct is prohibited.

[4] The Election Supervisor’s prior findings that Rules violations occurred in disputes between Frankian and Scott do not relieve Frankian of his burden to prove retaliation in this case. Each protest must be decided on the evidence presented in the record before the Election Supervisor.